NOT JUST ANOTHER TEEN IDOL

Shirley Steinberg's picture

Nothing is ever as it seems.  Descriptors about American Idol contestant Adam filled the air:  flamboyant, too much, too theatrical, Broadway, too much...comments on makeup and wardrobe choice.

Apologists are now saying that John Mayer-light singer Kris was the better singer.  Hogwash...Adam was clearly the most talented, unique, and entertaining of any contestant in the  too-long running show.  He was just too gay.

And so it goes...when will Americans tell it like it is?

I dedicate this indignation to LUNA.

AttachmentSize
images.jpg2.93 KB
Login or register to tag items

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
lizjmeyer's picture

the size of the red states & Kris' Idol/idle "win"

I saw the outrage on everyone's Facebook posts after Kris won. Someone noted: well, the red states won.  Another comment on the Sprinkle journal page was from a straight woman who admitted to pining over Adam and how straight men are losing out by being blinded by their own homophobia.  Its so true- why can't we just admit that desire is desire, sexy is sexy, talent is TALENT?!  But queer sex is too dangerous and the hint of it through guy-liner and theatricality is enough to lose the popular vote.  Because that's all it is--- its not truly a talent contest, but a popularity contest.  Who is most palatable to the most people willing to pick up the phone and dial and dial and dial? Personally, I'm grateful that Adam didn't win.  Maybe this means he won't be ground down by the Idol machine and will get a chance to let his individuality and personality shine.  The winner of Idol is whoever connects best with those most likely pick up the phone and compulsively hit redial.  So, those who are idle get someone else's Idol.  It just speaks to the demographics of the show, I guess.  I'm just thrilled Adam got to reach the millions he did over the length of this show and beyond. Adam: Rock on with your bad self!!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Tags for NOT JUST ANOTHER TEEN IDOL