plthom3's blog

plthom3's picture

Closing the achievement gap, accountability, health, and poverty

Most of the bureaucratic calls related to education ascribe accountability to schools and teachers, ignoring the powerful influence of children's lives on everything they do, including their educationa outcomes. . .Please consider this new study on health and student achievement linked at my poverty blog: http://livinglearninginpoverty.blogspot.com/2010/03/accountability-healt...
paul thomas

plthom3's picture

School choice and children in poverty

The claims and advocacy surrounding the school choice movement receive disproportionate coverage while solid and peer-reviewed studies remain in the background. Some recent examples of the problems created by choice and the misinformation surrounding advocacy groups publishing "reports" that are flawed: see my poverty blog. paul thomas

plthom3's picture

Of Maxine Greene and Howard Zinn

Was struck this morning by a new piece of mine just making "print" (available in the online Journal of Educational Controversy) concurrent with the passing of Howard Zinn. In the middle of the piece about teacher education and Greene, I turn to the work of Zinn: "Of Rocks and Hard Places—The Challenge of Maxine Greene’s Mystification in Teacher Education"

paul thomas

plthom3's picture

My response to the "stray animals" comment in my home state

My Op-Ed regarding the Bauer comment equating the poor to stray animals is in The State today: Baure's comments reflect our own misconceptions.

plthom3's picture

The poor are little more than stray animals?

All, this is what it is like in 2010 in the Deep South. . .maybe in a perverse way people are so committed to their prejudices that they believe them "right" so they actually say these things. . .this is from a leading contender for GOVERNOR in the state of SC:
"My grandmother was not a highly educated woman, but she told me as a small child to quit feeding stray animals," Bauer told a Greenville-area crowd. "You know why? Because they breed.

plthom3's picture

MLK Jr Day 2010

For many reasons, today is a reminder to consider the power of words and action: "You may well ask: 'Why direct action? Why sit ins, marches and so forth? Isn't negotiation a better path?' You are quite right in calling for negotiation. Indeed, this is the very purpose of direct action. Nonviolent direct action seeks to create such a crisis and foster such a tension that a community which has constantly refused to negotiate is forced to confront the issue. It seeks so to dramatize the issue that it can no longer be ignored." From MLK Jr's letter written in a Birmingham jail. . .paul thomas

plthom3's picture

New series from Sense

Please consider submitting and announce this where you can; I am editing a new series with Sense (PDF attached for distribution):

plthom3's picture

The oppressive weight of intellectual isolation. . .

I am an anxious person by nature. . .
People are apt after being around me for a while to say something like, "You're from here?"—meaning the South. And I have to say that I am. I am a son of the deep and disturbing South. . .South Carolina. . .
Recently I sat socializing with professors from my university and I recounted the story of my showcase lesson I taught when being interviewed for the position I now hold. After my lesson I was given an interesting piece of advice: "You may not want to say to your students that you are a Marxist. . ." And this was a nearly hushed moment of caution. . .

plthom3's picture

My Op-Ed on Duncan/Obama in The State (Columbia, SC)

Here is my newest Op-Ed, addressing the soaring rhetoric disguising business as usual at the Dept of Education: http://www.thestate.com/editorial-columns/story/1056960.html

plthom3's picture

New Op-Ed

plthom3's picture

Duncan continues to be wrong and wrong

Secretary of Education Duncan continues to be wrong and wrong: http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2009-09-23-duncan-education-refor.... The current administration maintains a commitment to failed accountability and testing paradigms that have never worked and will never work. Duncan's call for "urgency" continues the crisis rhetoric that has never worked and will never work. Critical educators must seek ways to enter this discourse and help all stakeholders in education understand that accountability/testing and urgency are prone to maintaining the status quo, not alleviating the burden of poverty that crippples children seeking education.

plthom3's picture

Poverty blog

All: I have begun and will be updating and maintaining a blog dedicated to poverty and education. . .this is initially being based on several scholarly pieces I have been working on and have had published over the past few years. . .feel free to suggest additions and please share as you see fit. . .I would appreciate feedback as well. . .

http://livinglearninginpoverty.blogspot.com/

. . .paul thomas

plthom3's picture

Arne Duncan on Face the Nation

Secretary of Education Arne Duncan was on Face the Nation this morning. . .and the interview highlights the huge problem we all face as we call for significant school reform. . .Duncan was wrong on nearly everything he said and Bob Schieffer just smiled. . .Duncan called for national standards, as if making statements about narrow expectations for everyone can work, as if we haven't been saying this for a century. . .Charter schools that work for everyone, merit pay. . .NCLB just needs better funding!. . the mantras are stale and not based in any evidence we know about the facts of school. . .Will we ever experince a political leader who knows her/his field? Who will say what we know is accurate?. . .I am skeptical. . .School failures are a reflection of social failures. .

plthom3's picture

What the average person reads. . .

While the discourse about education among scholars has nuance and some degree of fairness, here are two examples of what is being said in the popular discourse about Freire, critical pedagogy, and social justice. . .troubling and unfair to say the least:

http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/miarticle.htm?id=4494

http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/miarticle.htm?id=4564

paul thomas

plthom3's picture

An Op-Ed draft. . .response?

Here is a draft of an Op-Ed I am working on related to the Sotomayor debate; any feedback would be appreciated:

plthom3's picture

Speaking against scripted curriculum and high-stakes testing. . .

I keep making this argument, but am not sure anyone listens:

CLICK HERE TO READ

plthom3's picture

Disturbing. . .

plthom3's picture

Intellectual property in a digital world. . .

A good article on the value of copyright and the push against it: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124199933659205011.html

plthom3's picture

In the spirit

I live in the South, maybe in 2009 very much the "south" of the South in SC. . .and the partisan bitterness and rightwing-as-norm are heavy as a blinding fog.

plthom3's picture

Other choices

I have an Op-Ed in The Greenville News calling for an end to the either/or arguments we tend to have about schooling, and of course, the market advocates are most likely to chime in: http://www.greenvilleonline.com/article/20090207/OPINION/902070336/1008/....

plthom3's picture

"You're a brave man. . ."

i was invited to speak this past Thursday eve and Friday to the parents (Th) and faculty (Fr) of a high school in the midlands of SC. . .they asked me to talk about the "boys crisis," literacy, and poverty. . .they heard me say we should be skeptical of anything labeled "crisis". . .they heard me talk about the insidious intent hidden in SAT data (poverty and gender and corporate deception). . .they heard me ask them all to reconsider why we view children (not just boys) as empty glasses needing us to fill them (with the middle-class assumptions we never question). . .they heard me argue with two or three teachers who openly disagreed with me (almost all English teachers. . .). . .and they heard me call for no one ever again to use the distorted programs of Ruby Payne addressing poverty in deficit ways. . .over and over faculty came up to me afterward and said quietly, "you are a brave man". .

plthom3's picture

Words matter

I will always have Joe in everything I do. Without his guidance, I would not have opportunities to speak as in this Op-Ed running today in my city paper: http://www.greenvilleonline.com/article/20090103/OPINION/901030317/1008

Continuing to grow the critical space—paul thomas

plthom3's picture

"You are from the South, aren't you?"

When people fret about "What is wrong with our schools?" it would have served them well to know Joe. What is wrong with our schools? They too often lack KINDNESS, intellectual and academic kindness. They too often lack PASSION, intellectual and academic passion. They too often seek anything and everything except that which is human, most human.

What schools need is Joe—and those of us moved and touched by Joe.

I am very sad to say that Joe and I failed to meet face-to-face. Once he visited my university and as fate would have it I was out of town at a conference. But Joe and I talked by phone. The first time, he laughed and said, "You are from the South, aren't you?"

Joe and I shared the odd baggage of our roots not mixing well with the traditional acadmic world. My deep Southern drawl does not jibe with my written text. And for it, like Joe, I do not apologize.

Syndicate content