George Sefa Dei's First Blog

George Dei's picture

My name is George Sefa Dei and I am currently Professor of Sociology and Equity Studies, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto (OISE/UT). My teaching and research interests are in the areas of Anti-Racism, Minority Schooling, International Development, Indigenous Knowledges, and Anti-Colonial Thought. Between 1996 and 2000 I served as the first Director of the Centre for Integrative Anti-Racism Studies at OISE/UT. For the 2007 – 2008 school year I have been a Visiting Professor at the Centre for School and Community Science and Technology Studies (SACOST), University of Education, Winneba, Ghana. In September 2007, I was Distinguished Visiting Scholar at the Adeniran Ogunsanya College of Education, Otto/Ijanikin, Lagos State, Nigeria]. In June 2007, I was installed as a traditional chief, specifically, as the Adumakwaahene of the town of Asokore, near Koforidua in the New Juaben Traditional Area of Ghana. My community responsibilities include helping to promote youth education in the town.

I want to share some of my experiences working with others in a local community to promote youth education, and also the relevance and implications of studying traditional plant medicine as an Indigenous knowledge system. On education: Within many rural communities in Ghana many youth are struggling through issues of education given the rising high cost of schooling and/or the inability to secure employment commensurate with their educational qualifications. Schools themselves are struggling through challenges of proving meaningful education that will help local communities address contemporary challenges. It is here that questions of educational and curricular relevance, trained staff, etc. come to the fore. A number of youth who have found education inaccessible have simply given up after receiving basic level education. In such cases the youth have resorted to other activities some inimical to their own well-being and future prospects. Local community leadership have become increasingly concerned. There is the realization of an important responsibility of community Elders to stir youth to a brighter future and education is generally seen as key to such success. For traditional Elders the responsibility to assist village youth in their education entails finding creative ways to get parents and the youth involved in education, organizing public forums of education and social development matters, liaising with state authorities about provision of educational resources in schools. We must use of offices in local communities to create dialogue, open doors and facilitate access to local peoples of the valued goods and services that allow all to contribute to social development. Personally functioning in my new role has meant coming up with a plan [devised with youth in schools and out of school] on ways to enhance education in the community. In later discussions I can share our initiatives with readers. But suffice it to say that as a traditional Elder I have come to appreciate how important it is for such traditional systems of authority to re-invent our offices and positions, shirk some ‘unproductive’ old roles and practices and to help create and respond to new roles and challenges that augur well for community, national and African development.
In the area of traditional medicine I have been working with faculty, staff and students at SACOST to examine local perceptions and attitudes on the practice use and importance of plant and traditional medicine in Ghana. While this area has received much attention in past studies there is not much literature of a cross-national study in Ghanaian communities on plant medicine as an aspect of Indigenous knowledge systems. Our work has involved trying to ascertain the extent and context of the knowledge, use and applications of herbal medicine in the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of particular ailments in local communities. We know that throughout local communities plant herbal medicines are used for a variety of health ailments, including treatment of common colds, malaria, controlling hypertension, and cholesterol levels. But what do we know from the point of view of the users of plant medicines in terms of local understandings of the effectiveness, why the use of such medications, the epistemological and philosophical groundings of plant pharmacology as an Indigenous knowledge system, the pedagogical and instructional relevance of such knowledge, and specifically, the implications for teaching science education in schools, colleges and universities.
Over the years a central research concern of SACOST has been how to promote school and community science education in Ghana and African contexts in general. As a Centre for research and innovation in science and community education the faculty, staff and affiliated students associated with SACOST are exploring some of the challenges and possibilities of Indigenous philosophies of education.
My interests in plant medicine lie primarily in its efficacy as an Indigenous knowledge system. African Indigenous knowledge systems offer some conceptual and practical questions as to teaching about Africa with implications for schooling and education in Diasporic contexts. Among the many questions for critical intellectual engagement of ‘teaching Africa’ are how to address distorted Eurocentric views of Africa, including White racism toward Africa, its peoples, and the African Diasporas? As an educator and researcher I see an important objective in uncovering how local knowledge systems inform issues about Africa, including the development of curricula and critical instruction in schools grounded in African-centred perspectives. Understanding plant medicine as an Indigenous knowledge is looking at the myriad ways local peoples utilize their creativity and resourcefulness to address current problems (e.g., health). In responding to contemporary development and education challenges I believe we need to place emphasis on the interplay of tradition and modernity, contestations over knowledge production in 'post-colonial' Africa, politics of ‘African development’, and the roles and significance of science, culture, gender, ethnicity, language, and religion in shaping knowledge systems. Over the years I have reflected on some issues from my graduate teaching experience. I have repeatedly witnessed a particular concern that emanates from particularly the students with interests in Africa. It is the processes of [in]validation and [de]legitimating of knowledges – how knowledges are produced and disseminated nationally/globally. Students have often queried why and how is it that certain knowledges count more so than other ways of knowing. There is a realization on the part of learners that knowledge is operationalized differently given local histories, environments and contexts. Unfortunately, the processes of validating knowledges fail to take into account this multiplicity of knowings that can together comprehensive speak to the diversity of the histories of ideas and events that have shaped and continue to shape human growth and development. In questioning the hierarchy of knowledges learners also allude to the problematic position of neutral, apolitical knowledge. It is important then in our teaching of Africa we lay bare and grasp the processes through which for example, Western science knowledge positions itself as neutral, universal and non-hegemonic ways of knowing, and furthermore seeks to invalidate and devalue other ways of knowing.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Joe Kincheloe's picture

Thanks for you comments, George.

George,

You know how much I respect you and the amazing work you have done over the last few decades. The indigenous research you write about here is so central to the Freire Project. We are so passionately interested in making sure that critical pedagogy is not a white male appropriation of a South American set of concepts. While people from all race, class, gender, sexual, and colonial positionalities are welcomed into our project, we are especially interested in learning from peoples all around the world who are often excluded from intellectual and unfortunately critical circles. The work that you do has been a source of great insight to me and I have learned much from your studies of indigenous knowledge and anti-racist theory and practice. Thank you so much for becoming a part of the Freire Project. I and a host of people around the world will continue to learn from you in the coming years. One cannot read any of my writing about critical pedagogy vis-a-vis indigenous knowledge without seeing your imprint on it.

Joe L. Kincheloe
Canada Research Chair in Critical Pedagogy
Faculty of Education
McGill University

emiliafonso's picture

Dei's blog

I am grateful tro have the oportunity to read more of your ideas. As a science teacher educator I have been reading some of your papers and book chapters and always found it very stimulating to my own reflections about education in African context. I am from Mozambique, and during my Master and PhD studies your articles where a good reference and continue to be now that I am back in Mozambique (I did my studies at SMEC, Curtin University, Australia).
The issue of validating knowledge or how knowledge is validated is indeed a key issue, in my view, especially in African context. In Africa and due mainly to colonization, seems to me that in many occasions the process to validate knowledge still uses colonial lenses … I have been insisting in this question: why is that in our schools the epistemology that reign is still only one, the one which has been here for many years and years? Why are we not able to validate diverse epistemologies (then we could validate diverse knowledge)?
emilia afonso

Joe Kincheloe's picture

Thanks Emilia

Emilia,

Thanks for your insightful comments to George. We are looking to connect the Freire Project to Africa in every way possible. A central dimension of the project involves making sure that critical pedagogy does not become only a white, North American, European "thing." The project has just opened a new partnership with critical pedagogues doing amazing work in Barcelona and the University of Barcelona and are looking to establish brother and sister organizations in Africa, Asia, and with indigenous peoples from around the planet. I have written elsewhere of the kinetic possibilities that emerge from a dialogue among critical pedagogues and advocates for social justice in diverse parts of the world. If you are interested in helping us with this, we would certainly appreciate it. Thanks for your contribution.

In solidarity,

Joe L. Kincheloe
Canada Research Chair in Critical Pedagogy
Faculty of Education
McGill University

emiliafonso's picture

Dialogue among critical pedagogues

Thanks for your response Joe. I really appreciate it. Of course I 'know' you from your writing ... Thanks.
Yes, I am very much interested in entering the dialogue with critical pedagogues from different parts of the world. Yes, there is a kinetic possibility emerging from the dialogue … it creates indeed so much synergy.

Best regards,
emilia afonso

Student from Shirley's class

Hi.  My name is Alejandro and I am a Masters student at McGill University.   I am also involved in various international educational programs.  My band has established contacts with other artists in Brazil, Cuba and Chile.  We are working on establishing international dialogues using hip hop culture.  Most recently we attended a Hip Hop symposium in Cuba where we had talks about many different elements in Hip Hop culture.  I am now convinced that Hip Hop, at it's best, is a music that is capable of uniting youth from across the globe.  Some examples of the workshops we  animated or attended include: the portrayal of women in Hip Hop,  the portrayal of ethnic minorities, capitalist culture, beatboxing, spoken word, and so on.   All international artist were lodged at the Martin Luther King center in Havana and in the evening we solidified our relationship through jams and communal meals.  This experience was unforgetable.  We are presently working on a similar exchange in Brazil.  Afterwards we have a dream to do shows on the African and Asian continents.   It is amazing what one can learn outside of the classroom.

I beleive that the study of critical pedagogy has been instrumental in our ability to adapt ourselves to new cultural environment.  All band members originate from different parts of the world.  Internally this has enriched each individual in the group, making us more sensitive to difference.  For the first trip to Cuba the spanish speakers taught the non spanish speakers in the group to the point where they were able to commnicate on a basic level.  For our trip to Haiti and Brazil, I have been studying the local languages in order to really make the most of our cultural exchange.  Everything that gets lost in transaltion will be made clear through the music. 

Meeting the Needs of Students

Ghana’s youth are experiencing what many other youths around the world are experiencing.  Even in North America, students in different communities feel that their needs are not being adequately met.  For years students have allowed themselves to be empty vessels waiting to be filled with knowledge and skills that teachers deem important.  In the past years more and more students have been questioning the reasons why they need to learn various concepts and/or ideas.  How does it apply to them and how does it fit into their life experiences?  Students want to be the master of their learning however they do not have the necessary skills to assist them on their journey.  Teachers need to change their ways of teaching.  They must ensure that they are able to teach the skills their students need to become critical thinkers and learners.  For decades their ideas have been suppressed.  Now that they are ready to become masters of their own learning, they do not have the proper skills. 

On the other hand, teachers feel threatened because they believe that they are giving up control in their classrooms.  They need to learn to trust that this is a mutual journey between teacher and students.  Teachers no longer need to be experts in all subjects.  What is most important is that they are able to facilitate the journey for their students.

 

I feel that the Quebec’s new curriculum has taken a step in the right direction.  Students learn to be critical thinkers.  Reflection is a major part of the process.  Students work together to solve problems relevant to them.  I have observed that when students take ownership for their learning, the dynamics of the classroom changes.  Learning becomes active, noisy, messy and most of all FUN.

 

Passionate Pedagogue's picture

Historiography

 

Thank-you so much for your informative blog. The issue of the importance of indigenous knowledge in shaping the historical discourse of a people is amazingly important in a day and age where globalization is draping the world in an ever-increasing curtain of “Westerness”. Kincheloe (2007) argues that it is imperative that critical educators search out specific forms of subjugated insights, in your case Ghanian plant medicine, as indigenous knowledge. He asserts that “indigenous knowledges are special forms of subjugated knowledge, that are local, life-experience based, and not produced by Western science.” He goes on to argue that “such knowledges are transmitted over time by individuals from a particular geographical or cultural locality.” I think that our concern as educators, as you so prolifically write, must become how to get our students into contact with these subjugated viewpoints. One problem that educators face when trying to expose students to indigenous knowledge, as Kincheloe (2007) aptly points out, is that “these are the very types of knowledges Western ideological education have tried to discredit and eradicate.” Kincheloe’s point here is directly related to Edward Said’s (1998) contention that indigenous peoples have been discredited from writing their own experiences by the political process of history making itself. Said argues that colonial powers especially in the Orient were able to rewrite the area’s history because the assumption was made that to produce knowledge “you [colonial powers] have to have the power to be there [colony] and see in expert ways things that the Natives can’t see.” Said makes note of the massive French surveys that Napoleon and his entourage wrote on the history of Egypt during their invasion of the region from 1798-1801 as a prime example of the subjugation of indigenous history.
 
Given that most of the books we have that are considered part of the Western historical “canon” are colonial and ethno-centric we must find other ways to help students acquire the valuable knowledge that indigenous populations have to offer. The problem becomes how? The reality is that while the people in academia blog online about Freireian concepts in terms of the marginalization of the oppressed and while scholars and theoricists write books on new categories of the real and the transformative power of imagination for the marginalized, the average school teacher in the West, will not come into contact with these ideas and oftentimes does not want to. I think our challenge as critical educators becomes finding practical ways to show teachers how indigenous knowledge can be located, accessed and researched by students. The West has emerged into a hub of information technology, we must use the mediums of technology at our disposal to transmit indigenous knowledge and inform our own students on how to access it. 
 
I spend hours combing the Internet looking for sites about the peoples I teach in my history classes written by the peoples I teach. Oftentimes the sites I locate are too complicated or tacit for students to understand. Other times, the sites (rightfully so) are so culturally-specific that a teenager with no cultural capital about the area or peoples involved cannot possibly understand them. This leaves little actual “indigenous” information that is accessible to students. 
 
I trust that during my career as a teacher critical pedagogues will work to create student-centered access to indigenous knowledge. My hope is that the information that we gleam from the invaluable contributions of indigenous peoples does not become relegated to university sociology textbooks or primers in critical pedagogy. While it is of course wonderful for graduate students and academics to take the lessons that Native Peoples the world over have to offer to heart, perhaps we should be weary of becoming Napoleon’s in our own right; publishing surveys of Native history by Natives that only serve the higher echelons of academia.
 
Works Cited:
 
Jhally, Sut (Directorr). (1998). Edward Said: On Orientalism. United States: Baseline Studio Systems & All Media Guide.
 
Kincheloe, Joe L. (2007). Critical Pedagogy in the Twenty-first Century: Evolution for Survival. In Peter McLaren, & Joe L. Kinchloe (Eds.), Critical Pedagogy: Where are We Now? (pp. 9-42). New York, NY: Peter Lang.
 
 
 

 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Tags for George Sefa Dei's First Blog